What are the challenges of providing feedback?
One challenge that I think we all face is that, while we are great at providing feedback on our own work, we tend to be terrible at providing constructive feedback on others' work.
We are so focused on making our own work perfect that we forget that there are also other people involved. And we can't just tell someone else to fix this problem or make this change; we need to tell them how we think they could make their own work better, so that they can understand the problem and make the necessary change themselves.
The challenge here is that we as programmers are so focused on the individual task that we forget to see the big picture. We are so focused on how a given part of the system works that we forget to consider how it might work in the whole system. That means that we might be able to point out a particular flaw in a programmer's code without having any idea of what the real problem is. I'm not talking about cases where we know exactly what the problem is. For example, the person may be writing the correct code but there's a bug in the rest of the system, or the person is using the wrong technology, or the person may be using a programming language that's not really appropriate for their task. In those cases, it's not hard to help, but that's not what we're talking about here.
The challenges here are that we as programmers are so focused on the individual task that we forget to see the big picture. In the case of the last example, we could try to help the programmer use the right language and the right technology. But there are often cases where we're not in a position to make those kind of changes. Sometimes the problem is that the person is in a situation where it's not possible to change anything about the technology they're using. Sometimes the problem is that it's too costly to change the technology they're using.
I'm not saying that we should never be concerned about the environment in which people are working. We should always try to make sure that the environment is appropriate. But it's important to realise that sometimes we don't have the power to change the environment.
So what should we do?
What is the hardest part about giving feedback?
What do you do when someone has made a mistake?
How can you be more constructive and helpful? How can you make more effective feedback statements? How do you give your honest opinion about performance? This short video clip provides some answers to these questions and more, as a member of an expert review panel. How it works: Expert reviews can be submitted directly to the school. You submit your expert review in writing. We then share your submission with the school and ask for feedback on it from the school's team. After that, we share your expert review in writing with the school.
Video clip on giving feedback. What if I get to know the person being reviewed and I don't have a good opinion of them? Our school reviews are based on objective criteria and not on people's opinions. Reviewers at our school don't know each other, so they are able to see the school in a new light.
Will my review be anonymous? When you submit your review, we need to know who you are. However, we also need to know what the school needs to do to improve. Our team members review the school based on the schools' own responses, not on your comments. The only feedback they receive is from the school's own responses.
How much does it cost to be on the Expert Review Panel? The price to participate in an Expert Review is determined by the number of hours required to complete the review. For example, a student reviewer can be on the panel for approximately four hours. The full fee is equal to the time spent on the panel plus travel and accommodation costs. We have found that this level of compensation allows participants to be completely satisfied with the process.
Who decides on the reviews that are given? We determine the schools to which our reviews will be shared based on the responses to our review surveys. The feedback we provide to schools is based on our own interpretation of the information provided to us.
Will schools use my feedback? We encourage schools to use our feedback and respond to it in a constructive way.
What are 3 barriers to feedback?
I have found that it is not enough for me to ask questions.
As I have learnt more about what people are feeling, I find it helpful to provide feedback and be supportive.
What are your greatest frustrations in working with parents? I find it frustrating when parents are not able to take time to talk to me about the challenges of parenting. So often we do this with a focus on the needs of our children.
Is there something that you would change as a parent? I would like to work towards being a parent who would not just listen to the story, but actually help and support the parent to build resilience. What was your parenting style before you became a mum? My style before becoming a mother was to keep to myself and take care of myself. But after becoming a mother I changed my approach to my life. I took care of myself but also made sure that I kept the household running so that I had time to take care of my husband, children and family.
Has your parenting style changed now that you have children? Yes. There are some things that I did not know before having children. I did not know that being around food all day could be difficult and can cause me to feel bloated and heavy. I also did not realise how hard it was to go to bed at the end of the day. I was happy with not getting enough sleep.
Do you agree with 'saying yes to everything'? I would like to say no to everything. It is a waste of time and energy.
Is there a thing that you do which is annoying? I dislike it when parents come and see me with a crying child in tow. I feel that they are showing me their emotions but do not trust me enough to talk about the problem. I want to be able to offer some advice and help them think about what is going on in their family.
Why is it so difficult to give feedback?
I have a client who has asked me to coach them to give feedback as part of their coaching process, but for some reason it is so difficult.
Why? It is about being fair to them, showing them that I value them, and yet they do not feel comfortable receiving what they need to hear. How can I make this easier for them?
You are not alone. Feedback and especially giving feedback is hard.
I am not sure where you are based in the UK, but here in the USA, most large corporations have implemented 360-degree feedback for years. And even if your firm does not have that tool, I bet they know someone who has. And if they don't, then why not introduce it and learn from someone who is more successful at giving feedback?
Let me tell you a bit about 360 degree feedback. The premise of the tool is that each employee has their own strengths and weaknesses, and as such each person needs individualized feedback on their strengths and weaknesses. This requires being empathetic, and able to listen without judgement.
What I want you to focus on, is this: Why does it seem so hard for people to receive feedback? We have all heard stories from people who have been hurt by others giving them feedback. In one common example, I have heard, I was told that I was really good at, but now I hear that no one else agrees with me. What's the point of this? The other person had no reason to say anything to you at all!
Now, think about this situation and the following. You never had an opportunity to learn how you thought a specific colleague perceived you. Why didn't you ever get to learn this? There are several reasons. It could because the team leader decided that learning how his/her employees actually view them is too time consuming. Or, maybe you were busy working and did not get a chance to talk to this person for a few weeks.
When someone is not very open to feedback, it doesn't matter what you say; they will be defensive and upset. Or, maybe you could say to yourself, I think that there is something wrong with me; I just never learn that I suck, and therefore I should get better at giving and receiving feedback.
Related Answers
What is feedback meaning and definition in education?
Giving and receiving feedback is a key process in l...
What is the principle of giving and receiving feedback?
Feedback is an important aspect of nursing that has received increasing attent...
What is the main disadvantage of feedback in education?
I am currently teaching a class at my university and w...