Why is L2TP over IPsec not recommended?
Here's why I do not recommend L2TP over IPsec. This is not a criticism or attack against Michael, just a suggestion: Many network admin and IT support teams do not use IPSEC for client connectivity (which I think is a mistake), but a common configuration with IPSEC is to protect any "work" IPs, while using PPTP or other type of VPN protocol on regular client IPs, so the VPN traffic itself travels through IPSEC. For example, it can be very useful to have L2TP over IPsec where one side of the site is an IPsec gateway that talks directly with an IPSEC server, while only exposing the regular corporate IPs to the public (if you have to expose certain clients, you could use a reverse proxy with L2TP over IPsec). With IPSEC, you would also need to have the same server configured as a RADIUS Server with each client IP assigned a unique "RADIUS-ID" and used during each login attempt, which takes up more resources. So, using L2TP over IPsec, your client side only uses the public side of IPSEC, while your server's IPs use L2TP over IPsec.
Here's another example - if you use OpenDNS for Domain Whitelisting, OpenDNS (even though its a firewall utility) allows you to do this easily: You can setup L2TP over IPsec by configuring OpenDNS with the "Use IPSEC" radio button option and enter the appropriate values for it. This allows your users access to the Internet from "Home" without any issues because OpenDNS uses the IPSEC VPN as their gateway into the Internet and only allows "outgoing" connections. (this would then allow any home router in between OpenDNS and your internet access provider to do the routing of the IPSEC packets rather than the normal NAT or firewall rules, which are more powerful and can do things like prevent IP address leaking).
Again, it may sound silly that L2TP over IPsec uses only the public side of IPSEC and that it will not allow your internal IPs to communicate behind the VPN gateways, but I believe that's only possible when you're using a L2TP tunnel created by your VPN service provider.
What is the difference between PPTP and L2TP IPsec?
This is a discussion on ?
Within the Tech Boards forums, part of the Tech Board Group category; Hello. I'm starting to configure IPsec and I've been reading a lot about it. However, I came across this statement: "PPTP and L2TP are two . "PPTP and L2TP are two protocols for implementing IPsec". So I'm asking myself: what is the difference between them? Can you provide a link to a comparison of them (which part/problems they have)? Thanks a lot! EDIT. Maybe my question wasn't clear enough. Does PPTP or L2TP differ from IPsec in the protocol itself? If so, which one? What I meant was, do they differ in what they encrypt? In other words: how would you configure these two protocols if you want to encrypt everything with IPsec? Re: What is the difference between PPTP and L2TP IPsec? P-PPTP is Layer 2 tunneling over Layer 3 IPsec. That means that when a packet is received it is tunneled through the IPsec tunnels to a remote endpoint. The remote endpoint then encapsulates the packets and sends them back out. This is quite similar to the PPTP over IPSec method.
L2TP is Layer 2 tunneling over Layer 2 IPsec. That means that when a packet is received it is tunneled through the IPsec tunnels directly to a remote endpoint.
In your example, you want to use Layer 3 encryption. Therefore you should use PPTP.
Originally posted by kw4l
What protocol should I use for my VPN?
- Network Engineer
======.
chrisan. Use an SSH tunnel via a remote VPN provider. You can either connect with SSH/Connect to your vpn on the server directly or with ssh tunnnel. The ssh tunnel allows you to route traffic via a local port on your machine. Your SSH daemon will only listen for connections on a particular port for the remote. Host, so the server's SSH daemon wont need to open a hole for a connection to. Your local SSH daemon. When traffic needs to be routed across the VPN this is what people use as the connection method. -----. Zwischenzug. A short answer: OpenVPN.
Is L2TP still used?
Most of the protocols on the internet are designed to do the maximum work for the minimum amount of bytes sent over the wire.
L2TP is no different. It's not a new idea, but it's also not a standardised one.
L2TP is designed to be a very low overhead, fast encryption protocol. It is designed to offer as much speed as possible with little overhead.
It provides an encryption solution, but it does so in a way that's easy to understand, easy to implement and highly secure. In fact, L2TP is considered to be one of the most secure ways to encrypt a conversation.
L2TP works by using the IPSec protocol to encrypt and authenticate the traffic. IPSec is not a new protocol, but it's been around since the late 90s. By using this protocol, it's possible to build a secure VPN that is both fast and reliable.
L2TP uses the IPsec protocols to provide encrypted tunnels between clients, or between clients and the service provider. L2TP operates on top of IPsec, which provides privacy and data integrity.
For example, if Alice wants to send an email to Bob, but she doesn't want it to be delivered to someone else, she can use her public key to sign the email to ensure it hasn't been tampered with. Then, Bob can use her private key to decrypt the email, and he will be able to read it without anyone else being able to see it.
You can use L2TP with a Linux server as the service provider. When the client connects to your server, it will use L2TP to establish an encrypted tunnel, then it can use IPSec to talk to your server directly.
Your server can have a number of L2TP VPN clients connecting to it. The clients will all share the same IPsec tunnel and will be able to talk directly to each other.
L2TP was developed by Cisco in 1999. It was designed to work with the following: L2TP is not a standardised protocol. At the time, L2TP was seen as a cheap, easy to use alternative to PPTP. It was considered to be a secure, low overhead, efficient and easy to set up encryption solution.
Unfortunately, it has never been well supported.
Related Answers
Is PPTP outdated?
Is it free or what? PPTP VPN, PPTP VPN. PPTP (Point-to-Point T...
What are the weaknesses of PPTP?
If you're connecting to remote computer or other networks, you can turn off PPTP to...
Are L2TP and IPsec the same?
As I understand it (and please don't take this as something that means I'm...